May seems to be a very busy month for everyone dealing with vouchers.
First the ECJ’s judgement in the case C-520/10 Lebera has been published on 3 May 2012, which was shortly followed by the text of the proposal for the new Voucher Directive changes to the UK voucher rules, effective as of 10 May 2012. Quite a busy week for a subject discussed for years without any major breakthrough.
Find out more
The Advocate General has given his opinion in the UK case of Lebara Ltd (C-520/10) at European Court of Justice (ECJ) concerning the supply of phone cards to distributors in other EU-States, which end users belonging in that same EU-State can redeem in return for receiving telecoms services (previously reported here). In summary, the Advocate General has suggested that the distributor, and not the card issuer (in this case Lebara) should be liable for the VAT due on the supply of telecoms services to end users. The reasons for this are that the distributor is either acting as an undisclosed agent of the card issuer or, in the alternative, because the card issuer makes a single supply of telecoms services to the distributor and the distributor in turn makes a supply to the end user.
Find out more
In its submission to the hearing, the European Commission adopted the approach favored by Lebara Ltd, suggesting that in such circumstances the supply by the TelCo (i.e. the card issuer) is liable to reverse charge VAT in the distributor’s country, and that the onward supply by the distributor to the end user is subject to local VAT in the Member State where the distributor is established. Find out more